Ask someone what makes for the perfect chicken salad, and you’ll hear a wide array of opinions on the must-have mix-ins for the best-ever chicken salad. For me, good chicken salad is ALL about the technique, and less about the actual ingredients. My recipe combines well-seasoned chicken, a rich mayo dressing, plenty of fresh celery, and a touch of acid. It’s then chilled until cold, giving the flavors time to meld and saturate the chicken, resulting in a refreshing, creamy, and super-satisfying healthy snack or meal. Make it as-is for a classic, reliable version, or use it as a jumping-off point to create your own perfect chicken salad. Keep reading on for all of my top tips on how to perfect this classic dish, and make it your own:
How To Make Chicken Salad
INGREDIENTS
- Chicken Breasts: You can’t have amazing chicken salad without perfectly cooked chicken that’s seasoned, juicy, and relatively lean. Including dark meat in a chicken salad is common, but I think it can make the overall dish a little too soft and fatty. Instead, poaching breast meat in seasoned chicken broth is an easy way to guarantee that you won’t be disappointed by dry, bland chicken. Choosing smaller breasts that will cook more evenly is key here. If you’re a bit pressed for time, a rotisserie chicken is a great option too, but fight the urge to shred the chicken. Chopping the chicken into bite-sized pieces allows for more even distribution of ingredients.
- Chicken Broth: You can use water here, but I definitely recommend chicken broth for the flavor it brings to the overall salad.
- Seasoned Salt: Ditto here—regular works, but seasoned will take this over the top.
- Dressing: Mayonnaise is king for creamy salads, but it needs a little help to keep it from weighing everything down. Adding acid in the form of full-fat Greek yogurt, lemon, and Dijon mustard will help keep things rich yet light and bright.
- Mix-Ins: In my book, the only mandatory add-ins for chicken salad are celery for crunch, some kind of onion (I like red for the pop of color), and leafy herbs (I <3 dill and parsley). Other than that, this is the fun part! Go nuts… or grapes, or avocado, or whatever your heart desires. Toasted nuts like almonds or pecans will add an extra layer of texture, and fruit will add a pop of sweetness. I chose chopped dill pickles for my ultimate add-in because of the layer of crisp, briny salt they provide. Whatever you go with, be sure to chop them into pieces all around the same size so that they distribute evenly in each bite.
STEP-BY-STEP INSTRUCTIONS
You’ll start by poaching your chicken breasts by combining them in a pot with broth and salt, then bringing everything to a boil. You’ll be aiming for an internal temperature of 165°, which should take about 10 minutes. Use your meat thermometer if you’ve got one!
Once your chicken is cooked through, set it aside and allow it to cool and rest for a few minutes. Once your chicken is cool, cut it into as uniform of cubes as you can manage.
Meanwhile, make your dressing by combining your yogurt, mayonnaise, parsley, dill, mustard, lemon zest, and lemon juice in a bowl and mixing until relatively smooth. You might be tempted to throw your crunchy mix-ins here too, but I found that it all mixes together better if you make the dressing first, then add the chicken to coat, and then add your mix-ins.
Add your chicken to the dressing, and stir everything together. Add whatever mix-ins you like, and stir to combine. Taste for seasonings (I usually have to add a good amount of salt here).
You can eat this right away, on its own or on a sandwich, but I usually like to get it into the fridge for a bit before enjoying it to let the flavors meld together more. You do you!
Storage
Chicken salad is an ideal make-ahead recipe because it gets better as it sits. Make it a day or two ahead of time, then store in an airtight container in the fridge until ready to serve. If you have any leftovers, store them in an airtight container in the fridge for around 3 days, and enjoy epic lunch sandwiches (and salads!) for days.
