When you want a hot slice of leftover pizza with bubbly cheese and a crisp crust, the microwave is usually the worst tool for the job.
Using your microwave to reheat your pizza ultimately leaves you with a rubbery, soggy slice.
You can skip the microwave entirely by using these three basic kitchen tools and appliances. Bring leftover slices back to life, sometimes tasting even better than when they first arrived in the box.
1. Oven or Oven Toaster
This is what personally first comes to mind at least for me. My household has been using a toaster oven ever since I can remember.
The logic of opting for an oven or toaster oven is if you are intending to reheat more than a single slice. It handles bulk reheating effortlessly.
Set your oven or toaster oven to 190°C. Place a baking sheet inside while it preheats. When you put cold pizza onto a hot surface, it jumpstarts the crisping process.
Bake for 8 to 10 minutes until the cheese is bubbling and the edges are crisp.
For a toaster oven, keep a close eye on it around the 6-minute mark since the heating elements sit closer to the toppings.
2. Air Fryer
Out of the three, using an air fryer is the fastest method. It circulates intense, dry heat, making it ideal for reheating one or two slices in just a few minutes. Plus, it does this without turning the crust too hard and leather-like.
Start by preheating your air fryer to 175°C. If your model doesn’t require preheating, just add an extra minute to the overall cooking time.
Place the slices in the basket. Avoid overlapping them so air can circulate evenly. Then, air fry them for 3 to 5 minutes. Make sure to check up on them on the 3-minute mark. Thin-crust slices take a little over 3 minutes, while thicker-crust or deep-dish slices need the full 5 minutes.
3. Frying Pan or Skillet
If you are in no rush but don’t want to fire up your full sized oven just for a few slices, the best way to achieve that crunchy bottom crust and melted, gooey cheese is to reheat on the stovetop frying pan or skillet.
Place your nonstick or cast-iron skillet over medium-low heat for about 2 minutes. You don’t need to add any oil or butter. The pizza crust already has enough fat to crisp up on its own.
Lay your slices flat in the dry pan and cook uncovered for 2 to 3 minutes until the bottom turns golden brown and crispy.
From there, add a few drops of water to the empty space in the pan away from the crust, then immediately cover with a tight-fitting lid, and lower the heat to low.
Let it steam for 1 to 2 minutes until the cheese is completely melted, transfer to a plate, and enjoy!
Not everyone is like me, willing to eat cold pizza straight out of the fridge. Sure, a chilled slice has its moments, save them for midnight emergencies. Bringing your leftovers back to a state where they taste fresh, or even better than when they first arrived, is completely possible.
Aside from using any of these three kitchen tools, avoid cranking the heat too high, as it can burn the bottom of the crust before the cold cheese on top has a chance to melt. Stick to medium-low on the stove and moderate temperatures in the oven.
Lastly, don’t reheat your pizza on a cold surface. Putting a cold slice onto an unheated baking sheet or pan lets moisture pool underneath the dough as it slowly warms up, guaranteeing a soggy bottom. Preheating your cooking surface solves this immediately.
Frequently Asked Questions
Using a microwave heats the water molecules inside the pizza, which steams the dough from the inside out and ultimately leaves you with a rubbery, soggy slice.
The air fryer is the fastest method, taking only about 3 to 5 minutes to circulate intense, dry heat for one or two slices without making the crust hard and leather-like.
No, you do not need any oil or butter because the pizza crust already contains enough natural fat to crisp up on its own in a dry, preheated pan.
After crisping the bottom of the slice for 2 to 3 minutes, add a few drops of water to an empty space in the pan away from the crust, immediately cover it with a tight-fitting lid, lower the heat, and let it steam for 1 to 2 minutes.
An oven or toaster oven is ideal for bulk reheating when you are warming up more than a single slice.
